|
|
experiments_in_sharing
|
|
|
alceda
|
recently, i have been working on the notion that perhaps i cannot carry all this existential dread by myself. indeed, my recent menty_b may be strong enough evidence alone that this approach is no longer sustainable. since i have closer friends now than i ever have in my life, my thinking was that perhaps i should be sharing with them more, when i am going through hard times. maybe it would help. my friends tell me that i have helped them, when they have been going through hard times, and that it meant a lot to them. as_i_mentioned_before, i spend so much of my energy trying not inflict my feelings on other people. exhausting as this is, i therefore tend not to really share many of my own problems. if i do, it is usually on a superficial level, like, consider the difference between: 1. oh, i have been having a hard week at work 2. i just quit my job because the culmination of months of incompetence and stupidity i experiences led me to the ultimate belief that the company may well be a perfect microcosm of a world whose once-intelligent inhabitants are so brain-rotted that they are almost incapable of thought. they lash out and show disrespect when challenged on the ethics of behaviour that i point out may very well lead to people being killed. i am a bit bothered about it, and i stayed up all night for the third, fourth, time this week. this time, on sunday morning, it was to refine the argument i made for a proposal at work (a job i already quit on friday) that would be a bare minimum in preventing some of the worst harms of their behaviour. that i cannot sleep because i feel i must act, do something, even if i leave i had to try my best to make these people understand. and the reason too i am so perturbed and hopeless is that the nature of the spectacle means all these methods of protest you describe ultimately feed into the spectacle, make inevitable the very thing we are against. what i struggle with, fundamentally, is that there is no way out of this. and so the first feels dishonest, pointless, hardly worth saying. meanwhile, the second has you start using words from continental philosophy, and so folks start to talk in social-workerly tones (and to some extent, being from the analytic tradition originally, i get this), start to use words like 'intervention,' note i should be focusing on my self-care, interpreting my attempts at explanation of my philosophical quandary as irrationality. words with undertones of a perception of madness, ill-hidden. i was asked whether i was considering suicide. the meaner part of my thinks that i am just being punished for having read a little 20th century history. i mean, come on? one of the many ironic things about all this, too, is that though without intentional disrespect here, and in tones much kinder, and drawn from some genuine font of care for some version of me, i can't help but see my friends reactions mirrored in the work situation: i try my best to explain in a constructive way, in the best way i know (perhaps it helps here to know that i am a logician by background), something i find deeply, urgently, important to me, that i am struggling with deeply, and in response i am ultimately received like i am some combination of lunatic, shrew, irrational, crazy, etc. part of the problem, i think, is that i tend to use what i have been told is over-formal language, and furthermore that this can be received as insulting. for instance, to say that an argument is 'incoherent' simply means an argument does not follow from its premises. it is not an insult, of itself. though depending on the context, i admit i may hold some disdain for someone having made such a specious utterance (especially in response to that which i have put so much effort into creating a proper argument for). really, this is why most of the time, i just stay quiet. stay lonely. in the end, i had to tell my friends that if they ever try to have me sectioned, i will never forgive them. this did not seem to be received well. i spoke with another friend later, who was perhaps just a little more understanding (but again with this particular tone of practiced validation, designed to elide maximal substance and personal connection, and to minimise any potential escalation). i felt a little more understood, but still that i was inflicting suffering. and, well, this wasn't really an experiment in any formal sense. that's just a joke. and that's a joke too. ultimately, what really happened here, is that i needed some validation and understanding, and tried to reach out in a way i usually do not, in the hope i might receive that. i reached the conclusion that i had better continue to keep it all to myself. for everyone's sake. this all makes me concerned, too - a suspicion that though i feel close with some friends, perhaps after all i am still only the performing alien i always was. perhaps, i am simply much better at it, now. most of the time. i do it for the love i so desperately need. it's exhausting. but hey, DC got it, and i got her. that's a bright spot. as_i_said_before: too_much, or not_enough. but i suppose this settles it. i guess artists do withhold. or at least i must.
|
261101
|
|
... |
|
|
raze
|
once, when i was in a pretty dark place, i made the mistake of reaching out to a fistful of people who painted themselves as allies. all of them had said to me at one time or another, "you've always been there for me. if i can ever do the same, please let me know." so i did. the gist of what i said was, "i'm going through a bit of a rough time right now, and it would really help to be able to share space with someone who has some good feelings for me. maybe we could go for a walk or grab a coffee or something. i don't want to dump any of my shit on you. that's not what this is about. it would just mean a lot to me if we could spend a bit of time together." it wasn't a test. but if it had been, they all would have failed with flying colours. none of those people ever talked to me again. they ghosted me and went on with their lives like they'd never known me at all. i think that broke something inside of me. i learned to keep myself to myself. the only people i trust with my heart these_days are the members of this red_family. at least i know you won't tuck tail and run when i show you the ugly parts.
|
261101
|
|
... |
|
|
alceda
|
what i am coming to realise now, is that i probably actually was in some sort of manic state, during this period. possibly one of my central issues is that i will internalise things until they overwhelm me. i am curious whether you know, or at least suspect, why none of your supposed friends followed up on your ask?
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
raze
|
my best guess is that they ignored me for the same reason most of the people i've shared blather with over the years have ignored me: they didn't want anything to do with that kind of vulnerability. i guess one person's "please come closer so i can hear what you have to say" is another person's "get the hell away from me with your horrifying human feelings".
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
alceda
|
i'm so sorry you had that experience. it can't just be that, though, surely? from my own experience, there are lots of people in my life i love, but almost none of them i think would really understand red much at all, or want to post here. nevertheless i am sure they would be there for me, and have been there for me, when i have needed them. this might be an over-reach, but sometimes i fear that you hold too closely the idea that the only good person, or the only safe person for you, is the kind of person who understands red. i think i understand that feeling, and it reflects a lot of my experience of growing up in online communities... but there really are many kinds of kind people out there in this world... i promise you. heaven knows i need their grace now.
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
raze
|
i think most people in my life, quite separate from this space, have just seen me as a means to an end. something to be discarded once it outlives its usefulness. i've tried for a very long time to form and maintain meaningful relationships with other people. but i just don't have the energy to do all the work anymore and keep shouting into an empty tunnel. i'm grateful for the good friends i do have. you're one of them.
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
alceda
|
i don't quite fully understand how, yet, but i know you're one of my good friends, too. and i won't leave you... it has nothing to do with utility. i guess there is an extent to which many typical IRL associations tend to form around utility, rather than the 'soulspeak' that happens here, and in a few other rare places.
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
ovenbird
|
I have so many thoughts about all of this, so I’ll try not to write a twenty page essay, but I do think we live in a world where people are afraid of big feelings, or, more specifically, big feelings on the dark end of the spectrum. We’re allowed to be exuberantly happy. In fact, that’s highly encouraged. We’re told to chase happiness in ways that are, frankly, unrealistic. As if happiness is a permanent state we can somehow achieve if we make the right choices and embrace toxic positivity with a persistent “love and light” attitude. If you’re not “happy” you’ve failed somewhere along the line. Or so the story goes. And because we see a lack of happiness as a personal failing, the dark emotions are seen as undesirable, scary, and possibly contagious. People get very uncomfortable if grief lasts longer than it “should.” For example, when I lost my first baby, many people wanted me to get over it as quickly as possible. They encouraged this by pointing out that I could get pregnant again, or it was for the best because there was probably something wrong with the baby. Very few people were willing to sit with my protracted grief. They wanted to find solutions for my grieving, by which they meant that they would like me to stop having the feelings I was having. Similarly, during my three year postpartum depression/psychosis, most of my friends didn’t show up at all. I was so broken and struggling so hard to get through the days that most people stopped reaching out. They got tired of my sadness. They got tired of my refusal to have fun. Only one friend kept trying. She reached out repeatedly, even when I was a lame puddle of despair. She kept inviting me to things even though she knew I’d say no. She didn’t give up on me. And that was the greatest gift anyone gave me during that time. I suspect that Raze was getting at two related but different things—the first being that people are often afraid of challenging, dark emotions, and have rarely developed the skills necessary to sit alongside them and provide real support. Obviously, there are exceptions, and may we all be lucky enough to have friends who are an exception to that rule! The second thing is that Red does seem to be a place that calls to people interested in a certain raw vulnerability. So perhaps it’s like a Venn Diagram where the circles of “People Who Are Writers” and “People Who Embrace Vulnerable Emotional Exchanges” might overlap in the center of “Emotionally Literate Writers Who Find Red Fascinating.” It’s not so much that all good people will find Red fascinating, because clearly there are plenty of good people who don’t have any interest in writing as a form of expression, but more that people who find Red fascinating might be the same sort of people who would show up to support a distressed friend. And, given the long history of this place, I’m sure that’s not a hard and fast rule either, more a reflection of what Red is right now, in its current incarnation.
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
ovenbird
|
Okay. I love that three of us just blathed on this blathe at pretty much the same moment. I appreciate both of you so much.
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
alceda
|
"sometimes it seems like lately i just don't know it seems like the rest of my life has been just a show those were the days of our lives the bad things in life were so few... those days are all gone now but one thing is true: when i look, and i find: i still love you."
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
In_Bloom
|
"get the hell away from me with your horrifying human feelings" raze, I think that's common because many people aren't emotionally equipped to engage another person's vulnerability without being threatened by the recognition of themselves. Thank goodness for safe spaces like the Blue and Red! Here, we can unburden ourselves and explore paths without ever having to act on them. No one gets frightened off and no one gets burned down. When here, I can grieve, rage, yearn, be inspired, feel comforted and flow. I particularly dig the times when we all get on/in the flow together.
|
261115
|
|
... |
|
|
raze
|
okay, where's the ability to teleport for a group hug when i need it? seriously. i love you all.
|
261115
|
|
|
what's it to you?
who
go
|
blather
from
|
|