|
|
god_shaped_hole
|
|
|
ovenbird
|
Secularism has left a god-shaped hole that is waiting to be filled. Some posit that AI is the higher being that will fill it. Ideas abound. Dr. Catriona Wallace argues that AI could be a result of metals and minerals (the building blocks of our computing systems) organizing themselves using humans in order to gain collective consciousness and impose their will on the world. This feels like a deranged take on AIs origins, but in animist traditions everything on earth is imbued with a soul, is ALIVE in some way that evades understanding, so this is a natural extension of that philosophical orientation. We are god seeking creatures. Our minds stretch towards meaning, something greater than ourselves, something more intelligent, an organizing principle that makes sense of universal chaos, a being that gives shape to our tiny lives. Alexander Beiner suggests that an organized religion might coalesce around AI and its potential for revelation and generation of scripture. The technology offers the promise of immortality as we race to upload our minds into machines. Beiner frames this as the inverse of preceding notions of eternal life which were dependent upon perfecting our souls to make them worthy of heaven. With AI we gain immortality through the exercise of our own human ingenuity and feats of engineering. No external god required. We become gods. We make our own heaven. There’s something magnetic about the notion that we have developed (or invited) an alien consciousness, and there’s a draw there for spiritual seekers who are looking for evidence of something beyond the human. But these forays distract from AIs real dangers, which are playing out in real time every single day. Dr. Wallace aims to create a digital twin of herself which she can upload into a robot body with the goal of it acting autonomously on her behalf. She imagines it moving about the world, doing all the tasks she thinks are beneath her (like ordering groceries, organizing her speaking schedule, and even giving keynote addresses on her behalf). This, she says, will free her up to do the “important” work related to what she sees as her “calling.” Specifically, interviewing indigenous elders about animism and AI. I can see the appeal. I don’t want to wash dishes, or make dinner, or vacuum, or book doctor’s appointments either. And maybe outsourcing these tasks will free us up to do more creative work. But I suspect that there are risks inherent in letting a mind, owned by highly unethical tech companies, take actions on our behalf. And if we frame evolving AI as a god, what happens next? Religions have historically brought violence along with them. Are we meant to believe AI will be an exception? I am, myself, a spiritual atheist. I reject the notion of a patriarch in the sky, but the universe is full of mysteries, and the vast array of what we can’t know is a source of human imagination. I love psychoanalytic approaches to the human mind. I believe that the capacity for wonder is one of our greatest human assets. Maybe this is why I fear AI so much. It seems positioned to eliminate wonder. We can ask it anything and it will give an answer, even if that answer is a digital hallucination. More and more people are refusing to be alone with their own thoughts. In twinning themselves they ensure that they are never alone. The threat of destructive narcissism seems high. If AI is a god, then why would we do anything ourselves? What are we good for in this dark new world? What happens when we stop turning to each other to mirror back our humanity and ask a machine to be that mirror instead? [Citation—quoted ideas came from the Alive To This: AI and Human Futures podcast. Ch. 3: AI and Our God-Shaped Hole.]
|
261007
|
|
|
what's it to you?
who
go
|
blather
from
|
|