amatonormativity
ovenbird I learned this word yesterday and…oof. It was coined by philosopher Elizabeth Brake. On her website (https://elizabethbrake.com/amatonormativity/) she writes:

“Amatonormativity is a word I coined to describe the widespread assumption that everyone is better off in an exclusive, romantic, long-term coupled relationship, and that everyone is seeking such a relationship. The belief that marriage and companionate romantic love have special value leads to overlooking the value of other caring relationships. I call this disproportionate focus on marital and amorous love relationships as special sites of value, and the assumption that romantic love is a universal goal, ‘amatonormativity’: This consists in the assumptions that a central, exclusive, amorous relationship is normal for humans, in that it is a universally shared goal, and that such a relationship is normative, in that it should be aimed at in preference to other relationship types. The assumption that valuable relationships must be marital or amorous devalues friendships and other caring relationships, as recent manifestos by urban tribalists, quirkyalones, polyamorists, and asexuals have insisted. Amatonormativity prompts the sacrifice of other relationships to romantic love and marriage and relegates friendship and solitudinousness to cultural invisibility.”

I think this plays into complex notions of how we’re ALLOWED to love people. We are meant to see friendship as a lesser relationship than marriage. We also have very strict rules about what does and doesn’t COUNT as friendship, even though relational categories are fundamentally slippery and involve a lot of overlapping grey areas. It is expected that friendships and familial relationships will be tangential to marriage. It is assumed that there is something about marriage that makes it “better” than these other relationships and, therefore, assumes the other relationships are disposable, whereas marriage is meant to be fixed and permanent. It also means that intense love for people (or pets even) that cannot be subsumed into the category of marriage or exclusive romantic partnership, is automatically seen as less fulfilling and less important. Assuming that marriage is the norm or pinnacle of human relationships rejects the possibility that there are other ways of being in relationships with other people that don’t conform to any widely accepted parameters.

What I keep returning to is that when we choose marriage we are asked to relegate other relationships to the background of our lives.

I recall a conversation I had with my mom once, a long time ago. She said that once she got married and had kids, that configuration (mother, father, children) became her primary “family.” She no longer thought of her own parents and siblings as her immediate family. I hadn’t yet left home at the time and I couldn’t imagine ever feeling that my own family of origin (my mom and dad and brother) were somehow less important than whatever family I created through marriage. But it was assumed that upon marriage (and possibly the arrival of children) that I would follow some naturally ordained path into “letting go” of my family of origin and building a family of my own.

In reality this never happened. I did get married. I had two children. And they never felt like they overtook the importance of my family of origin. I still felt like my family of origin was a context in which I could be most fully and freely myself, and my family through marriage involved a lot of complex attacks on my identity and general sense of who I was. Ultimately my family of origin represented a certain safety that my family through marriage couldn’t reproduce, and I was left feeling that I was “doing it wrong.” But “wrong” hinged on the assumption that it’s natural and normal to separate from a family of origin and relegate them to a distant supporting role in your life.

I think this assumption deprives us of love and care and support that could allow us to live more fully and with more connection and joy. It extends beyond familial relationships as well, forcing friendships into narrow boxes that leave no room for exploring their potential intensity and importance. And it forces marriage into narrow boxes as well. For instance, a “platonic” marriage feels like an oxymoron. But why? Could it not be theoretically possible to be in a married partnership with someone that you don’t have sex with, but you might parent with or build a future with?

I have a lot of questions. Questions that are suddenly becoming urgent at mid life when I am facing the not so distant loss of my own parents, and struggling with the lack of availability of some friends who are very much drowning in their own complex lives and don’t have time or capacity for frequent interactions.

If anyone has thoughts on this one, have at it! I’m so curious about the lived experience of others.
261105
what's it to you?
who go
blather
from