death_wish
ovenbird “Would you choose to die if you were in my place?”

There is no way to answer this question. I can’t tell if it comes down to love or if it comes down to fear. (It’s both, as it is always both.) Do you love this life enough to suffer to your natural end no matter what that suffering entails? Are you more afraid of bodily oblivion or mental oblivion? Does answering either of these questions actually clarify anything? Not really. Or at least that’s how it seems to me.

Because dementia, like death itself, is an unknown entity. No one who travels to either place can tell us what it’s like to be there. A person lost inside their own sputtering mind can’t tell us what that experience looks like. Who knows what horror or beauty exists inside a state of dissolution or if there is still something worth living for in the emptiness of a self set adrift.

We keep asking, “What if it’s terrifying?” Because those of us with our minds intact can barely think of a worse fate than to lose access to the thing that defines our eternal “I.” But we don’t dare ask the opposite question: “What if it’s extraordinary?” What if it returns us to the realm of sensory pleasures that we experienced as babies, before language, before self awareness, before agency? If we believe that a newborn baby can experience worthwhile joy, is it not possible that someone reduced to a similar state due to dementia could experience that same joy? Is lucidity required to have quality of life? Or are there more primal routes to delight based in our most visceral and elemental experiences of emotion and awareness?

A person with stage 7 dementia won’t remember their own experiences, but neither does a baby. My very first memory occurred at the age of two, and I didn’t start forming regular memories until around five years old. But no one would say my life wasn’t worth living in those five years. Is value rooted in the potential for growth and development? A baby will grow to have more complex experiences, but at the end of life there is only entropy, more and more chaos in the system until it reaches death. If there is no potential for “improvement” does a life cease to have value? A person in late stage dementia no longer has access to their logical mind, factual memory, their narrative self, or conceptual coherence, but research suggests that they do maintain access to the deepest emotional processing centers of the brain. Is it necessarily terrifying to return to the state we experienced when we first entered the world? Was it terrifying to know love without a word for it? Terrifying to be held in safe arms? Terrifying to hear a soft voice singing?

I have no answers at all. Just endless questions. And that’s when I always turn to Rilke, who said:

“I want to beg you, as much as I can, dear sir, to be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and to try to love the questions themselves like locked rooms and like books that are written in a very foreign tongue. Do not now seek the answers, which cannot be given you because you would not be able to live them. And the point is, to live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the answer.”
260906
what's it to you?
who go
blather
from